Git Remote Annoyances on Windows

I use a few machines and just want them all to work. Problem is that never happens and I run into stupid things that keep popping up so… I’ll document it in case anyone else is getting frustrated by the same nonsense So you’ve got a new repo on github and you want to copy-pasta the commands to setup the remote+push.. thats alright until..
> git remote add origin git@github.com:DanBradbury/smashRecordKeeper.git
> git push origin master
Permission denied (publickey).
fatal: Could not read from remote repository.

Please make sure you have the correct access rights
and the repository exists.
Only reason I knew what to do was because I banged my head against the wall to start off a Ludum Dare.. the issue here has to do with the current auth being in conjunction with git@github.com: linkage.. if we just use the https remote all will be fine.. pretty silly
> git remote add otro https://github.com/DanBradbury/smashRecordKeeper.git
> git push otro master
Counting objects: 290, done.
Delta compression using up to 4 threads.
Compressing objects: 100% (286/286), done.
Writing objects: 100% (290/290), 2.59 MiB | 1.24 MiB/s, done.
Total 290 (delta 38), reused 0 (delta 0)
remote: Resolving deltas: 100% (38/38), done.
To https://github.com/DanBradbury/smashRecordKeeper.git
 * [new branch]      master -> master
and now we can git as expected on Windows w/ credential file auth (might popup in other cases.. but dont really want to test that stuff)

Git Auth when Windows Credentials are Locked / Just want to use file

Most Windows users won’t run into this problem because they don’t have a system administrator controlling their machine but for anyone who is experiencing weirdness while using wincred here’s a brief explanation of the problem + an easy fix to get things back up and running.

The wincred issue that I was facing was anytime I ran powershell as a non-administrator I would be prompted for my Username/Password and rather than it being persisted I would get a fun CredWrite failed error and would be prompted again on each subsequent git related call. At first I was at a total loss and was running everything as an admin just to avoid that annoying prompt when trying to pull/push/etc. I finally decided enough is enough and started doing some digging on how windows creds were being persisted on my machine.

Upon looking up the CredWrite failure it became clear that this was a Windows specific Git credential manager that I was oblivious to. The default storage on Windows is something called wincred, which is essentially a Windows built-in credential manager that can be accessed via Control Panel

Unfortunately for me when I drill into the manage page I get the following

Welp that explains the CredWrite failure I was seeing all over the place. Since I was unable to use the recommended a git-credential-store helper I had to resort to using the store –file option to get things working as I’d expect on any other machine (less than ideal but worth it to not be forced to type my username/password every time I wanted to git)

There are a few options to disable the Git Credential Manager (detailed here) but here’s the method I used to get unblocked:

  • git config –global credential.helper “store –file ~/.gitcredentials”
  • Create gitcredentials file and place my creds in there according to the specified format
username=myuser
password=mypass
  • git config –edit –system
  • Remove the helper = manager line that is still in the system even though we specified to use the file for cred info
  • Celebrate because we can git without being prompted every time!

The main issue I had was that I thought setting the file store in (1) would be enough but still ran into the problem where the cred manager was still being used. Checking the global config is critical to ensure that things are going to work as expected and it’s not a bad idea to know exactly what’s going on at the global level